"Bullshit is all the reasons we give for living. And if we can't think up any reasons of our own, we always have the God bullshit. We don't know why we're going through all this pointless pain, humiliation, decays, so there better be someone somewhere who does know. That's the God bullshit. And then, there's the noble man bullshit; that man is a noble creature that can order his own world. Who needs God? Well, if there's anybody out there that can look around this demented slaughterhouse of a world we live in and tell me that man is a noble creature, believe me: that man is full of bullshit."
The soliloquy you just read was delivered by Peter Finch in the role of downtrodden, world-weary news anchor Howard Beale in the 1976 classic film Network. Beale, disenfranchised with society, and his role as an influential newsman, uttered those prophetic words on the air during one of his final broadcasts for the fictional Union Broadcasting System (UBS).
Over the course of the five months (has it been that long already?), I've heard many people say that Deborah's passing was all part of God's Great Plan. We may not understand it yet, but there's a reason for everything.
To that, I say: bullshit.
Organized religion is one of the most vile, evil things in the world. It teaches people to hate, fear, and judge others who may hold different beliefs or live a different lifestyle than their own. People do and say awful things in the name of organized religion - and I'm talking about all organized religions. Wars are fought, innocent people are killed, and people are harrassed for their beliefs.
Since I was very young, I came to several beliefs about the existence of God. God does exist, of that I was certain (or as certain as one could be without any hard evidence, but that's what the word "faith" means). There is historical evidence of the existence of Jesus Christ, though scholars now debate the time of his birth and death. His resurrection is, of course, what causes the most contention.
It's true, there is little indisputable proof that Jesus Christ, the son of God, rose from the grave or so loved the world that he died for our sins. Oh sure, there's the Bible, but - and what I'm about to say will no doubt be controversial to many of you - I have always viewed the Good Book as sort of like the Telephone Game. There is a reason there are different versions of the Bible, and throughout multiple revisions, edits, and changes, the original message may have become contaminated along the way.
Having said that, the core tenets of the Bible remain strong foundations to live your life by. You shouldn't kill, steal, commit adultery, take advantage of others, or worship material things. I think of the Bible as sort of a collection of parables - not unlike fairy tales - that should be used as a guide to live a good, honest life. Do I believe there was a talking snake or a boat big enough to carry two of every species of animal? No, because I'm a logical person and I see the physical impossibility of such things. Considering how many species of animal there are in the world, the boat itself would have to be more than half the size of the planet to carry two of them all. Suggesting there were fewer animals back then only raises the question of where the rest came from, since evolution and creationism do not go hand-in-hand for many people.
What I choose to believe may be hard for some people to accept or understand, but so much of organized religion preaches belief through fear. Deborah and I didn't even see eye-to-eye on our beliefs, though we ultimately reached the same basic conclusion, so I don't expect anyone else to.
All my life, I chose not to believe in the vengeful God you heard about in the sermons of your youth. The God who would condemn you to an eternity of fire and brimstone if you didn't follow a very specific set of rules, or most egregiously, didn't believe in Him. I had often heard atheists and agnostics say, "If there really is a God, how could he let bad things happen to good people?" The answer, I thought, was simple: God does not play favorites. As hard as that may be to accept, God does not get involved in our lives. He sits back and lets us make our own choices, then judges our actions when our time comes. God doesn't create murderers, idolaters, warmongers, rapists, thieves, and all the evil people of society any more than he creates the pillars of integrity and kindness - at least, not directly.
After Deborah was abruptly taken from me, I tried to rationalize it. I tried to believe in the notion that it's all part of the "Great Plan," but several thoughts continued to nag at me. If, indeed, life is pre-ordained, and we are all merely playing our part in accordance with our predetermined destiny, what becomes of free will?
Think about it. God gave us free will, correct? If life was pre-ordained, doesn't that contradict the very notion of free will? If everything we do is part of some plan - every step we take, every decision we make - then we really don't have free will, do we? If life is all predetermined, then by implication God is responsible for murderers, rapists, and all the evils of society because, for some reason we can't fathom, it was part of His plan. I don't know about you, but I sure don't want to believe in that.
"Let me give you a little inside information about God. God likes to watch. He's a prankster. Think about it: He gives man instincts. He gives you this extraordinary gift, and then what does He do - I swear for His own amusement, His own private, cosmic gag reel - He sets the rules in opposition. It's the goof of all time. Look, but don't touch. Touch, but don't taste. Taste, don't swallow. And whil you're jumping from one foor to the next, what is He doing? He's laughing His sick fucking ass off! He's a tight-ass! He's a sadist! He's an absentee landlord! Worship that?! Never!"
Al Pacino delivered those lines as John Milton, the earthly guise of the Devil himself, in the 1997 film The Devil's Advocate.
Right now, some of you are probably mortified. You're praying for my soul, and you're already typing up angry, outraged responses, or pleas for me to rejoin the flock. "Beg for God's forgiveness." "God loves you, don't turn your back on Him." Do me a favor. Stop. Hit delete. Don't bother. If anyone should be seeking forgiveness, it's God.
There are two options, the way I see it. First, God is as I always suspected - omnipresent, ever-watching. Watching, not doing. He sits back and watches His creation take shape. He watches us suffer, watches families torn apart by violence, cities leveled by natural disasters, and babies starve to death. He watches it all... but He doesn't do anything about it.
If God doesn't get involved, He cannot be responsible for your blessings, but by way of inaction is responsible for all of life's hardships, ugliness, and sorrow. How could I worship something that has the power to make things better, but simply chooses not to?
The second option is that we are following a cosmic plan. Free will is a myth that makes us feel like we're in control of our lives, but in reality we're all just playing our roles. The logical conundrums in this scenario are almost too numerous to point out.
We are taught that God is infallible. That's the biggest argument against the theory of evolution - the implication that God made a mistake and changed something, or that He is not in complete control. Fine. But if God is infallible, that means He is responsible for everything that happens, good and evil. Sure, God got you that great job, blessed you with a beautiful family, and handed you that bitchin' sports car you've always dreamed about. But he also created Ed Gein, Jeffrey Dahmer, Osama bin Laden, Ted Kaczynski, Adolf Hitler... You see, God cannot only be responsible for the good and not the bad if, indeed, we are all acting in accordance with the plan - and free will could not logically co-exist with the plan, because that implies that God is not in complete control.
So which is it? Does it even matter? Why should I thank God for my blessings, but refrain from blaming Him for my pain? Why does He get a free pass? How can anyone or anything receive all the credit and none of the blame if it supposedly created the entire world and life as we know it?
Of course, there is always the third option: that God does not exist. Neither science nor religion has been able to adequately and definitively prove how all life began, after all, so I have to allow for the possibility that Deborah's death, and all of life's misfortunes, are a simple case of mathematics. Bad things happen, and sooner or later, you or someone you know are bound to be a statistic. In this particular example, I'm told Deborah had roughly a four percent chance of surviving. Those are nearly impossible odds, and unsurprisingly they did not work out in her favor. Our bodies weren't built to last, and there is so much about them we still don't understand.
We choose to believe in the afterlife because it comforts us. For many, it gives people something to strive for - a reason to live a good life. It is a frightening thought that death is the end, I admit. It's a thought that has kept me up at night and given me anxiety attacks. The idea that I will simply cease to be, and all of my memories, my experiences, will fade away with me is not one I prefer to entertain. I would like to believe that the person I am will continue on after my physical body has decayed. But how can I put my faith in anything that would let so many bad things happen? Moreover, why should I need convincing that living a good life is the right thing to do in the first place? Shouldn't we all strive for peace, prosperity, and happiness, regardless of whether or not it results in a potential reward when we die? Most importantly, why should I grovel at anyone else's altar for things I've worked hard for and be thankful when they're taken away?
Yes, I'm angry. I've been angry since July 6th, 2011 when Deborah died at just 33 years of age, and if you have any common sense you will shut up. If you've read this far, you've done so of your own volition. This is my blog, and these are my feelings, and you will not change them, so don't even try. You can quietly judge me as a heretic in the comfort of your own homes all you'd like, but I don't want to read your comments, opinions, suggestions, or preaching. Shut your mouths. Stop typing that comment or that e-mail. Do not try to win me back because all you will succeed in doing is making me angrier, and this time my anger will be directed at you.
I don't want to hear about how Deborah's death has a greater meaning and we just can't comprehend it now, because I don't believe it and it doesn't change the pure logic that God is either directly or indirectly responsible for the suffering of all humanity, whether through His plan or through observation rather than interaction. If God exists, maybe He is not loving and merciful. Maybe He is vindictive and arrogant. How dare we question His plan?! How dare we not worship Him?! How dare we not thank Him for everything we work for. God didn't give me a job. God didn't buy me a car. God doesn't pay my mortgage. God didn't win Deborah's heart. I earned all those things through hard work, and you're fucking right I'm proud of myself, so if pride is a sin then you might as well send me to Hell.
Maybe God is a big kid with a magnifying glass and we're all ants. He's a schoolyard bully, demanding our lunch money and we give it to Him out of fear of retribution. I bet most people who read this post will react with revulsion and call it blasphemous, but if God is as loving, forgiving, and understanding as you'd preach, what would it matter what I say or believe? Would He not understand my anger, my sadness? Were we not created as imperfect beings and, thusly, should we not be forgiven for our imperfections, fears, doubts, and faults? Instead, He demands homage. He demands recognition. He demands credit for everything we accomplish, but we absolve Him of all blame for fear that he will deny us entry into his exclusive club. He's a cosmic bouncer with an inferiority complex, standing behind His velvet rope and taking out His issues on people who he feels have wronged Him.
You're all free to believe whatever you want, whether that's in the Christian God, an alternative deity, universal forces, multiple gods, or nothing at all. All I ask is that you extend me the same courtesy and do not try to convince me of anything opposite of all I've said here. I will not live my life in fear of eternal damnation or in hopes of salvation. I will not live my life for anyone other than myself. From this point forward, I will live my life the best way I see fit - in a manner that pleases me and not some entity watching over me, silently cataloguing and judging everything I do for His Naughty or Nice list.
I have always said that intelligent people can discuss religion, whereas ignorant people will argue about it. With that in mind, I must reiterate that I do not expect to see a single e-mail or comment telling me I'm going to Hell. These are my personal beliefs, and I expect everyone to respect them and leave me to them. I have chosen to share them purely as a therapeutic release, not to invite your judgment or opinions. I don't care about your opinions, quite frankly. If I did, I'd be reading your blog and not the other way around.